The Fall of Man
Maria Elena Buszek makes the argument that the
pin-up, while it can be sexually explicit, is not necessarily a means to
repress women as it often actually liberates them to break away from the
stereotypical ideal woman and reclaim a sense of power. For Buszek, the pin-up
is a form of "awareishness" as it attempts to help women of every part of life. The art
works for the New Woman, flappers, and suffragettes, as well as housewives and
the government by increasing numbers of women volunteering. As such, Varga,
the pin-up artist Buszek focuses most of her energy on, creates images as
enticing but not inviting, which work as an opening to making women erotic
subjects, as opposed to mere erotic objects, thus assisting women in their work
to regain power over themselves (Lecture 3). However, not all of Varga's images
serve feminist agendas. While they have an affective aspect, in which they
create planned emotions, they also have unplanned reactions. As they shock the
status quo, they also become potentially harmful, particularly to women who
become affected by the monster beauty present in the images. Regardless of the
aim to embrace different "types" of the Ideal Woman, pin-ups
essentially work as an oxymoron—their attempts at using sexuality as a kind of power meant to
regain autonomy and create environments of equity and equality, also depend
greatly on the viewer and the gaze. A pin-up is still a pin-up, and the overall presentation
is still a form of sexuality accepted by men only because it does not threaten
them too much, and accepted by some women only because it does not always
completely objectify them.
Many of the images
Varga created contain controversial, and debatable aspects. For example, the
included Varga pin-up has Christian, and pagan, allusions present. It is incredibly suggestive of Eve—the Mother of Humanity,
according to biblical references of the creation story in Genesis. Varga's Eve
exists after the Fall of Man: When Adam and Eve were created, "the man and
his wife were both naked and were not ashamed" (Genesis 2:25). It was not
until after the two had eaten the fruit from the tree in the middle of the
garden that they became aware of their nakedness: "[T]he eyes of both were
opened, and they knew that they were naked. And they sewed fig leaves together
and made themselves loincloths" (Genesis 3:7). In the pin-up, rather than
being fully clothed, the woman has been strategically covered with leaves and
vines, just as Genesis alludes to. However, this moment in the story is
particularly interesting because God has not yet discovered what they have
done. It is not until the following verse that God becomes aware of their
transgression, and only in Genesis 3:21 that God makes garments for them from
animal skins. Thus, Varga's Eve is in a position of sinless sin—the gravity of
her actions has not yet been made clear, and she has not been burdened with
being the reason behind the Fall of Man.
Nonetheless, the
gravity of the situation is not underplayed by Varga's depiction. The woman is
the very image of entice but not invite as she holds the apple in her hand and
motions to the viewer with her finger. Her standing position, as well as her
jutted hip and semi-turned torso, imply a certain sense of an unsaid direction
to "follow me [her]." The lasso in her right hand has just recently
been used to hook the viewer—just as it was used to hook Adam—in order to
mislead them into some kind of perceived sinful behavior. Though, again,
because of the moment in history this Eve has been positioned in, the behavior
would not be totally sinful, only frowned upon. In this way, Varga reflects not
only on the position of the Woman in culture, but also of the Woman as seen on
the pin-up. She has been given unprecedented power as she is capable of
altering the very fate of humanity, and is, at the same time, rejected for
holding such power.
However, Varga has
not just created a woman, he has created a goddess. The pin-up has super-ceded
that of Eve clothed in fig leaves: Varga's painting depicts a golden woman.
Everything—her shoes, her lasso, her hair, her apple, her vine-like coverings,
her skin, her headpiece (much like a crown)—is gold. In this way, she becomes
more than human but nearly becomes a statue to be worshiped. She is truly a
goddess, and her attempt to become as knowledgeable as her own God in regard to
good and evil only further demonstrates this.
A medieval
expectation of knights and chivalry involved an idea referred to as fin
amor, in which a woman was elevated above a man to become goddess-like,
similar to Venus. The woman was never to be won over by the knight as obstacles
were to continually appear and disrupt potential happiness. In fin amor,
pain is the equivalent to pleasure. Varga's pin-up demonstrates this: The woman
he creates is utterly unattainable both by men and by women as she does not
actually exist, particularly obvious through the monster beauty she
depicts.
Again, this points
to Varga's reflection upon the Woman. While he points to the power and agency
of a woman, he only points to it insomuch as it functions as power used wrongly
and as a form of destruction rather than productivity and goodness. She is
merely of the flesh, and not of the spirit. Varga's pin-up allures, just as the
snake allured Eve into sin. It is possible then, that this Eve serves as a
warning to take care in placing trust in a (potentially) promiscuous woman,
but also of women in general, as they all stem from the same lineage of Eve:
The cause of the Fall of Man. In her enticing, she warns the viewer to not come too close,
lest Man fall yet again.
Bibliography
"Book of Genesis - ESV." Bible Study Tools, www.biblestudytools.com/esv/genesis/.
Buszek, Maria Elena. Pin-up grrrls: feminism, sexuality, popular culture. Duke University Press, 2006.
Whaley, Deborah Elizabeth. Pin Up Grrrls: Feminism, Sexuality, Popular Culture (Powerpoint: Lecture Three). 2017.
Comments
Post a Comment